764 Phil. 373
CARPIO, ACTING CJ.:
A perusal from the records of this Office disclosed that on November 13, 2007, a letter was sent to Mr. Mendoza requiring him to submit monthly financial reports for Judiciary Development Fund (JDF) for the months of June 2005 to present; Fiduciary Fund (FF) for the months of January 1997, November 2001, May 2006, and March 2007 up to present; Special Allowance for the Judiciary Fund (SAJ) for the months of June 2005 to present; and General Fund for the month of May 2003. Another letter dated January 29, 2008 was sent again to Mr. Mendoza requiring him to submit the aforementioned reports. On April 14, 2008, a letter requiring him to show cause within a non-extendible period of five (5) days from notice why his salary should not be withheld for failure to comply with office rules and regulations on the submission of monthly financial reports on the aforementioned funds for the said periods. Notably, on June 16, 2008, this Office recommended the withholding of the salaries of Mr. Mendoza for failure to comply [with] the abovementioned directives, which was APPROVED by then Chief Justice REYNATO S. PUNO on June 30, 2008. His salaries were withheld starting July 2008.The OCA approved the recommendations. It docketed the matter as an Informal Preliminary Investigation (IPI), furnished Mendoza with a copy of the Memorandum, and required him to comment thereon. The OCA further directed the Fiscal Monitoring Division, Court Management Office (CMO) to conduct a financial audit in MTC Gasan to determine if there were any shortages in the court's funds.
In a letter dated March 03, 2009. Mr. Mendoza admitted his remorse for being remiss in the submission of his monthly reports of collections, deposits, and withdrawals, explaining that it was primarily due to the peculiarities of his function as Clerk of Court of MTC-Gasan, Marinduque. He further explained that he has also been acting as Court Interpreter for several years already, making, checking and reviewing all the transcript[s] of stenographic notes taken during the hearings, that is, in addition to the functions he has to perform as a Clerk of Court. He further stated that it was not his intention to defy the rules and regulations of this Office, contesting that all collections were properly deposited with the Land Bank of the Philippines, and [he] did not utilize it to enrich nor benefit him to the detriment of the government. In view of Mr. Mendoza's submission of the abovementioned required reports, this Office recommended the release of his withheld salaries, and that he be severely reprimanded with a stern warning to be more circumspect in the performance of his duties, and that a repetition of the said acts will be dealt with more severely. The Honorable LEONARDO A. QUISUMBING, then Acting Chief Justice, APPROVED the aforesaid recommendations on December 03, 2009.
In a letter dated March 07, 2012, Mr. Mendoza was again required to show cause within a non-extendible period of five (5) days from notice why his salary should not be withheld for failure to submit monthly financial reports on JDF for the months of March 2010 up to present; SAJ for the months of March 2010 up to present; FF for the months of March 2010 up to present; and the newly required quarterly General Fund report for the 1st quarter of 2009 up to present. For failure again to comply with the said directive, on September 10, 2012, this Office was constrained to submit the following recommendations to the Court, to wit: (a) withhold the salaries and all allowances of Mr. Jose V. Mendoza; (b) relieve him as Clerk of Court; and (c) conduct of an immediate financial audit in the books of accounts of MTC, Gasan, Marinduque. Notably, the aforementioned recommendations were approved on September 21, 2012, and the salaries of Mr. Mendoza were withheld starting October 2012.
In a letter dated October 15, 2012, Mr. Mendoza narrated a family problem he had with his daughter and admitted his being remiss in the submission of the required financial reports. Mr. Mendoza did not state any further explanation and requested for the release of his withheld salaries and allowances. In a letter dated November 26, 2012, this Office informed Mr. Mendoza that recommendation for the release of his withheld salaries and allowances could only be effected upon submission of the required financial reports. Records of this Office disclosed that up to date, Mr. Mendoza has still failed to submit reports for JDF for the months of March 2011 up to present; SAJ for the months of March 2011 up to present, FF for the months of March 2010 up to present, and General Fund for the 1st quarter of 2009 up to 2nd quarter of 2010, and 4th quarter of 2010 up to present. Notably Mr. Mendoza seems to submit unsatisfactory explanation whenever required to show cause for his failure to submit the monthly financial reports. Records show that there was repetition of his misfeasance despite opportunities given to him by the Honorable Court.
In view of the foregoing, this Office respectfully submits the following recommendations for your Honor's consideration and directive, to wit:
1. defer the release of the withheld salaries and allowances of Mr. Jose V. Mendoza, Clerk of Court, MTC, Gasan, Marinduque;
2. retain the relief of Mr. Mendoza as Clerk of Court and direct the Executive Judge/Presiding Judge to designate an Officer-in-Charge in his stead; and
3. refer the herein matter to the Legal Office, Office of the Court Administrator, for evaluation of any appropriate legal sanction the circumstances may warrant.[1]
(1) that Mendoza be found guilty of Simple Neglect of Duty and fined in the amount of Five Thousand Pesos, with a stern warning to be more circumspect in the performance of his duties, and that a repetition of the same or similar offense will be dealt with more severely;
(2) that Mendoza be required to submit himself to the Supreme Court Medical Services, Manila, for medical examination, and that the Supreme Court Medical Services be directed to submit to the Court a Medical Report and Certification from the Head of the Medical Services whether Mendoza's physical pains render him incapable of effectively discharging his duties as Clerk of Court;
(3) that the Finance Division, FMO-OCA be directed to release Mendoza's withheld salaries and allowances considering his submission of the required reports; and
(4) that the Presiding Judge of MTC Gasan be directed to strictly supervise his accountable officer to ensure strict adherence to the Court's circulars and other issuances on the proper handling of judiciary funds.
The following guidelines and procedures are hereby established for purposes of uniformity in the submission of Monthly Reports of Collections and Deposits, to wit:The directive of OCA Circular No. 113-2004 requiring the submission of monthly reports of collections of court funds and fees is mandatory.[4] Mendoza's transgression already happened before when his attention was called on 13 November 2007 about his failure to submit the required monthly financial reports. It resulted to the withholding of his salaries starting July 2008 until he complied with OCA's directive. Yet, despite the previous warning he received to be more circumspect in the performance of his duties, Mendoza again failed to comply with OCA Circular No. 113-2004. It even came to the point that the Court had to form an audit team to look over Mendoza's accounts. The Court did not have to utilize its resources if only Mendoza had been more conscientious in performing his responsibilities. The records also showed that even when his attention was called in 2012 to submit the financial reports, he still failed to submit the reports and only fully complied in February 2014.
1. The Monthly Reports of Collections and Deposits for the Judiciary Development Fund (JDF), Special Allowance for the Judiciary (SAJ) and Fiduciary Fund (FF) shall be:1.1. Certified correct by the Clerk of Court2. The following documents shall be attached to the reports:
1.2. Duly subscribed and sworn to before the Executive/Presiding Judge
1.3. Sent not later than the 10th day of each succeeding month to-The Chief Accountant
Accounting Division
Financial Management Office
Office of the Court Administrator
Supreme Court of the Philippines
Taft Avenue, Ermita
ManilaA. For Judiciary Development Fund (JDF)3. In case no transaction is made within the month, written notice thereof shall be submitted to the aforesaid Office not later than the 10th day of the succeeding month.a. Duplicate copies of the official receipts issuedB. For Special Allowance for the Judiciary (SAJ)
b. Machine validated deposit slips, if collections are remitted/deposit[ed] with the Land Bank of the Philippines (LBP), or Postal Money Order (PMO), if collections are remitted through PMOa. Duplicate copies of the official receipts issuedC. For Fiduciary Fund (FF)
b. Machine validated deposit slips, if collections are remitted/deposited with the LBP, or PMO, if collections are remitted through PMOa. Duplicate copies of the official receipts issued
b. Machine validated deposit slips, if collections are deposited with the LBP, or certified true copies of the official receipts issued by the Provincial/City/Municipal Treasurer, if collections are deposited with the Treasurer's Office
c. In case of withdrawal:c.1. Copy of the Court Order
c.2. Original Official Receipt (OR) or certified true copy of OR
c.3. Duplicate or certified true copy of withdrawal slip and disbursement voucher if collections are deposited in a savings account with the LBP, or a copy of the check and disbursement voucher if collections are deposited in a current account with the LBP, or disbursement voucher, if collections are deposited with the PTO/CTO/MTO
c.3.3. [sic] Copy of the acknowledgment receipt